Holidays?
Is it a sin to celebrate a holiday with pagan origins, like Christmas and Easter? And what about Halloween?
-C.J.
Dear C.J.,
Let's deal with Christmas firsts. Christmas was a pagan holiday that gradually became associated with the Birth of Christ. By the fourth century, various dates were proposed for the birth of Jesus. Eventually December 25 was chosen. This replaced the pagan winter solstice festival. Most believers accepted this and the holiday was popularized in the 19th century. By the mid-twentieth century, Christians had accepted almost universally the practice's celebrating the holiday.
However, there was always opposition to the celebration. The reasons were usually either (1) too much partying and drunkenness, or (2) its association with paganism. People have the right to choose to celebrate it or not. Do they have the right to condemn someone who does celebrate?
The answer, biblically, is found in Romans 14. There Paul deals with the issue of differing beliefs among believers. Neither one has the right to judge the other. As Paul says, one esteems all days alike and one esteems some days as special. What is key is that if you think they are wrong (sinful) then they are wrong. However some believe that we can take pagan symbols and Christianize them. This is what has been done with the cross. A symbol of death has been turned into the most important Christian symbol of life through Jesus Christ. This would answer the objections to the pagan practices associated with Easter as well.
What about Halloween> This pagan festival dates back to the ancient Druids. They believed that this night ghosts and spirits were most likely to wander about. Wearing costumes and trick or treating were added after 1900 and became a commercial success in the 1950's. Christians have treated it in two ways. First, it is a purely secular holiday to be celebrated or not. Secondly, some have objected to its pagan origins and view the celebration as somehow giving support to the Devil. Again, based on Romans 14, a day is what we make of it. A symbol is what we interpret it to be. The meaning always lies with the individual.
Where Christians get in trouble is that they are too prone to call everything a conviction. Here is my definition of a conviction. A conviction is something I am willing to die for. Everything else is a preference. For example I am willing to die for my belief that Jesus is the Son of God. I am not willing to die for my preference in water baptism (which happens to be immersion). When we understand this truth then we will dial the rhetoric down.
-Pastor Jimmy Dickens
